Food and Life
Korean Society for Food Science of Animal Resources
Review Article

Modern trends and techniques for food preservation

Ambreen Talib1,http://orcid.org/0009-0001-4988-202X, Abdul Samad2,https://orcid.org/0000-0002-4724-3363, Md Jakir Hossain2https://orcid.org/0009-0008-7663-9202, Ayesha Muazzam3https://orcid.org/0000-0002-5155-6629, Bushra Anwar1https://orcid.org/0009-0002-7244-2687, Rameen Atique1https://orcid.org/0009-0001-4032-3686, Young-Hwa Hwang4https://orcid.org/0000-0003-3687-3535, Seon-Tea Joo2,4,*https://orcid.org/0000-0002-5483-2828
1Department of Pathobiology and Biomedical Sciences, MNS University of Agriculture, Multan 25000, Pakistan
2Division of Applied Life Science (BK21 Four), Gyeongsang National University, Jinju 52852, Korea
3Department of Animal and Dairy Sciences, MNS University of Agriculture, Multan 25000, Pakistan
4Institute of Agriculture & Life Science, Gyeongsang National University, Jinju 52852, Korea

† These authors contributed equally to this work.

*Corresponding author : Seon-Tea Joo. Division of Applied Life Science (BK21 Four), Gyeongsang National University, Jinju 52852, Korea. Tel: +82-55-772-1943, Fax: +82-55-772-1949, E-mail: stjoo@gnu.ac.kr

© Copyright 2024 Korean Society for Food Science of Animal Resources. This is an Open-Access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution Non-Commercial License (http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc/4.0/) which permits unrestricted non-commercial use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original work is properly cited.

Received: Mar 04, 2024; Revised: Mar 12, 2024; Accepted: Mar 12, 2024

Published Online: Mar 30, 2024

Abstract

Food preservation is the process of stopping or inhibiting the spoilage of food that prohibits foodborne diseases while keeping the food’s nutritional value, flavor, and texture. Food preservation plays a vital role in food safety and quality. Food preservation techniques are also helpful in meeting the global food demand as these techniques provide an opportunity to store food for a long time. Food safety techniques, like salting, drying, and fermentation to increase the shelf-life of raw food, have been used since the dawn of humankind, and our ascendants must have used these techniques. A wide range of chemical and biochemical reactions could be the root of food spoilage. So, appropriate preservation is necessary to stock the food for as long as possible without contamination. Primary and fundamental techniques like drying, freezing, pasteurization, biopreservation, and Nanoencapsulation have been instigated to stop or slow down food's chemical and biochemical destruction. Bio-preservatives are now commonly used to meet people’s demand for food preservation as chemical preservatives are rejected. This review summarizes the various physiochemical and microbial components that cause food spoilage and the use of different food preservative techniques like salting, dehydration, freezing, smoking, irradiation, antimicrobial agents, preservatives, and nanotechnology in the food industry during processing and packaging.

Keywords: food spoilage; food preservation; biopreservatives; nanotechnology; food processing

Introduction

Food is an organic substance that can be in solid or liquid form and can be absorbed, digested, and assimilated in the body of an organism to gain the energy that the body needs to work, repair tissue, grow, and perform other vital processes. It consists of all the essential nutrients like proteins, fats, carbohydrates, vitamins, and minerals (Pinstrup-Andersen, 2009). It can be obtained from animal or plant sources (Harlan, 1976). The demand for food production is rising remarkably due to increasing population and changes in food diversity (Davis et al., 2021; Samad et al., 2024). As foods are nutritious enough, they can be spoiled by physical, chemical, and microbial processes (Rahman and Labuza, 2007). According to the World Health Organization (WHO), about 1 out of 10 people become ill from eating spoiled food. According to Fouladkhah et al. (2019), 420,000 people die every year due to food poisoning. It has been observed that during food transportation, the surrounding environment, including bacteria, chemicals, and the enzymes present in food, can cause changes in the morphology of food and reduction of nutrients in food (Gram et al., 2002). Thus, the food needs to be preserved to avoid spoilage by contamination and maintain food quality. Food preservation increases food stock storage and shelf-life without affecting nutritional values and qualities (texture, aroma, freshness, flavor, color). Food Preservation is also helpful in avoiding the oxidation of fat in food by inhibiting microbial growth (Prokopov and Tanchev, 2007). Food preservation is also known as food processing (Lianou et al., 2016; Necidová et al., 2019). The history of “Food Preservation” goes back to ancient culture when primary troops felt that there was a need to preserve food when a large animal could not be eaten at once. Similar basic techniques were applied to keep food in a distant society, which was the utmost evolutionary step (Nummer, 2002).

The food industry is trying to design new, less invasive technologies (use of high pressure, hurdle technology, radiations like UV light, Oscillating Magnetic Field) beyond the traditional conventional methods like drying, freezing, chilling, curing, heating, boiling, sugaring, salting, canning, pickling, and fermentation (Blum, 2012; Rahman, 2014). Bio preservatives are alternatives for preserving food to keep its characteristics, which is also helpful in fulfilling the demands of people who want to consume chemical-free food. Bio-preservation is a technique used to control microbes by adding natural antimicrobial compounds to increase the shelf-life of food products. It also uses beneficial bacteria to prevent spoilage and make pathogens inactive. Bio preservatives act by lowering the pH, changing the water activity, and adjusting the redox potential of food products (Rehman, 2020). Lactic acid bacteria (LAB) are widely used to preserve food (Gemechu, 2015).

Packaging is the other most crucial method of preserving food and providing all the necessary information regarding food products for commercialization (Davis and Song, 2006; Raheem, 2013). The properties of packaging depend upon the type of food that has to be protected. Commonly used packaging materials are paper, cardboard, glass, metal, and plastics (Kishimoto, 1990). While these materials cause pollution, the reaction between packing material and food may harm quality and health (Muzeza et al., 2023). Therefore, intelligent packing, in which technology is used to sense or monitor the overall quality of food, is considered. This approach may directly improve food safety by interacting with food. In intelligent packing, researchers apply bioactive substances (antioxidants, antimicrobials, moisture absorbers) to preserve food (Vasile, 2018). Another approach is biodegradable packaging, an alternative to conventional materials that are easy to produce, degrade, and recycle (Davis and Song, 2006) and mainly used to preserve fruits and vegetables (Butnaru et al., 2019).

Moreover, nanotechnology is the latest approach to food preservation (Chandra, 2016). Due to its excellent physiochemical and antimicrobial potential, nanomaterials are used in crop protection, food processing, and conservation (Baranwal et al., 2018; Fu, 2014). Nanotechnology is now used in food to produce desired properties (Sandoval, 2009); these are used as biosensors and packaging materials. However, there is a problem with nanotechnology as it could be more cost-effective for food processing (Adabi et al., 2017; He and Hwang, 2016). Considering the need for food preservation to avoid poisoning, spoilage, and other infirmities, this review pursues the traditional and latest food preservation techniques. This review also presents the implementations of nanotechnology in the processing, packaging, transport, and storage of food. Moreover, it explains the prevailing struggles to address the risk-related factors and toxicological effects of packaging in food sectors.

Classification of Foods

Food classification is done on various occasions, as discussed in Fig. 1 and further explained below.

fl-2024-1-19-g1
Fig. 1. Basis for classification of food.
Download Original Figure
Food classification based on shelf-life

There are three classes of food based on the shelf life of food (Perishable foods, Non-perishable foods, Semi-perishable foods).

Perishable foods

They can be stored for several days to 2–3 weeks (e.g., seafood, meat, milk and its products, poultry, eggs, and all cooked leftovers). They become spoiled if not refrigerated.

Semi-perishable foods

They can be stored for several months (about six months) under appropriate storage states (e.g., vegetables, fruits, cheese and potatoes, ginger, and biscuits).

Non-perishable foods

They are naturally processed foods with unlimited life and can be stored for several years (e.g., dry beans, nuts, flour, sugar, canned fruits, peanut, butter, mayonnaise, dry meat) (Jones and Lennard, 2020).

Food classification based on functions

Based on the functionality of food, they can be classified into two classes.

i) Bodybuilding and repairing hoods, ii) regulatory and protective food, iii) energetic foods.

Bodybuilding and repairing foods

Body-building and repairing foods increase the body’s mass and repair cell and tissue damage, e.g., milk, meat, fish, vegetables, and nuts (Fakolujo et al., 2024).

Energetic foods

The foods that provide energy for the movement are called energetic foods, e.g., oil, butter, sugar, cereals, dry fruits, and starches (Gupta and Kaur, 2023).

Regulatory and protective foods

The foods that regulate the body through homeostasis and protect the body from external pathogens are called regulatory and protective foods. Water, raw vegetables, beverages, milk, meat, and fruits are regulatory and protective foods (Singh et al., 2023).

Food classification based on nutrients

Carbohydrate-rich foods are based on nutrients like rice, wheat, and starchy vegetables. Protein-rich foods include milk, meat, fish, eggs, and nuts. Oil, butter, and egg yolk are excellent sources of fat enrichment. Vitamins and minerals can be obtained from fruits and vegetables (Hoque et al., 2023).

Food classification based on the extent of processing

There are three classes of food based on their processing.

Unprocessed foods

Foods that are not processed or may be physically processed to make whole food more available. It makes food to preserve for more time. This includes fresh fruits, vegetables, nuts, pasta, tea, and coffee.

Processed foods

Those foods are those in which components of food are extracted to make it prepared for dish cooking. Vegetables, sweeteners, pasta, and noodle preservatives fall into this category.

Ultra-processed foods

Foods that are processed culinary to produce accessible, palatable, and readily available foodstuffs with longer shelf-lives (e.g., cakes, biscuits, bread, chocolate, milk drinks, sausage, salted, pickled, smoked, meat and fish, fish canned in oil) (Monteiro et al., 2010).

Food Spoilage Mechanism

The process that causes the reduction of food nourishing ability is known as food spoilage and is related to food safety (Steele, 2004). The extent of food spoilage can be determined by chroma, aroma, flavor, and taste. The mechanism of food spoilage is elaborated in the Fig. 2. Various factors that are the cause of food quality and causing food spoilage are explained below.

fl-2024-1-19-g2
Fig. 2. Factors affecting food quality and causing food spoilage.
Download Original Figure
Physical spoilage

Physical spoilage occurs due to gain or loss of water or humidity, water movement between compartments, and their separation (Roos and Karel, 1991; Steele, 2004). Moisture content (Balasubramanian and Viswanathan, 2010), temperature (Kader et al., 1989; Steele, 2004), and crystallization (Levine and Slade, 1988) are physical factors that cause spoilage.

Microbial spoilage

It is the most common method of food deterioration. Microorganisms like bacteria, fungi, molds, and yeasts cause food deterioration and foodborne illnesses, especially in highly perishable foods. It can be prevented by lowering pH, controlling water activity, adjusting temperature, properly packaging, and using preservatives (Tianli et al., 2014). Nutrient concentration, water content, pH, and redox reactions are intrinsic factors of food spoilage (Steele, 2004). Meanwhile, humidity, temperature, and the presence of microorganisms are extrinsic factors (Steele, 2004). Antibiotic resistance is the major issue while microbial Spoilage can be controlled by antibiotics (Samad, 2022). So, we need to use an alternative to stop microbial spoilage.

Chemical spoilage

Physiochemical and biochemical reactions naturally occur in food, which may cause color, odor, texture, and taste changes. Microbial activity and metabolism, redox reactions, proteolysis (Igarashi et al., 2007), hydrologic rancidity (Steele, 2004), putrefaction, and toxic compound production are factors that cause chemical spoilage of food.

Food Preservation Methods

There are several food preservation methods, which are explained below and also shown in the flow chart Fig. 3.

fl-2024-1-19-g3
Fig. 3. Flow chart diagram of food preservation method.
Download Original Figure
Physical methods
Dehydration

Dehydration or drying is the process of removing all the water content from the food items. The process of evaporation is used for drying purposes. It is one of the oldest preservation methods (Alnadari et al., 2023). After dehydration, microorganisms’ growth is inhibited; they cannot cause spoilage as all the enzymes work at specific water activity, while in this process, moisture is lowered to the point where their functionality is lost (Rayaguru and Routray, 2010). Most microbes grow at 0.95 water content and do not grow when water is lowered to 0.88 (Troller, 1986). It has diverse advantages, as lowering the density and quantity of food is the cheapest way to preserve food (Agrahar-Murugkar and Jha, 2010) and making it easy to transport, store, and pack food. However, it also causes loss of aroma and flavor, vitamin C, proteins, lipids, and thiamine in dehydrated food products (Amit et al., 2017). Drying and freeze-drying methods preserve fruits, fish, vegetables, coffee, and tea.

Pasteurization

Pasteurization is a process in which food is heated to destroy all types of bacteria and enzymes (Shenga et al., 2010) to extend the shelf life of food items and keep them fresh for a longer period (Vieira et al., 2018). This process kills almost all pathogenic bacteria, yeasts, and molds, but the temperature and duration should be optimal. They must not destroy the vitamins and proteins of foods. This process is known to French scientist Loius Pasteur, who used this technique for the first time to preserve milk and milk products. Wine and beer are also treated by this process (Alsaedi et al., 2023). Modern procedures like low-temperature long time (LTLT), high-temperature short time (HTST), and ultra-high temperature (UHT) are also accessible (Boye and Arcand, 2012). LTLT is done on small plants (Salvato et al., 2003). This process must control proper holding and prevent overheating or burning (Rahman and Labuza, 2007). HTST is done to perish the pathogenic microorganisms. It is a continuous “Flash Pasteurization” (Salvato et al., 2003). UHT is done to restrict heat-resistant spores and is more effective than LTLT and HTST (Poushi and Sharifi, 2024). Foods are heat-treated and aseptically packed in sterile containers. High heat treatment pasteurization causes a loss of 20% of vitamin C, 10% of thiamine and vitamin B12, and 5% of calcium and soluble phosphorus, but this loss can be considered lower from a nutritional point of view (Rahman and Labuza, 2007).

Freezing

Freezing is an ancient method that reduces the physiochemical and biochemical reactions and thus inhibits or deteriorates the growth of pathogenic microorganisms (Rahman and Velez-Ruiz, 1999). This method is preferable over canning and dehydration because it is effective for the long-term preservation of food and reduces metabolic responses (Fennema et al., 1973). In this method, water activity is reduced, and the temperature is reduced to 18°C or lower (Fennema et al., 1973). Though they have a vigorous and effective capacity to control pathogens, frozen foods are not acquired in developing countries. So, it is not widely used in industrial food preservation, but in upper-class and uptown, freezers are widely used (Amit et al., 2017). In recent years, freezing has been widely used to preserve fruits, vegetables, and meat. Meat contains 50%–75% water; it is converted into ice cubes in the freezer, which occurs at –20°C (Dave and Ghaly, 2011).

Chilling

Chilling is the process that reduces the initial temperature of food goods and maintains that temperature for a long period (Mercier et al., 2017). It is a short-term food storage as it reduces the physiochemical reactions and extends the shelf-life of fresh foods (Martínez and Carballo, 2024). The chilling rate is determined by the initial temperature of food, water content, amount of food, and equipment used for chilling food, and it can be done by an ice bank cooler, plate heat exchanger, or cryogenic chamber (James and James, 2023). It prevents the oxidation of lipids, deterioration of color, autolysis of fish, nutritional concentration, and moisture loss. However, at the same time, it puts down the crispness of food and dehydrates the uncovered food goods (Roudaut and Debeaufort, 2010).

Irradiation

Irradiation is the physical method of food preservation which results in disinfection, inhibition of sprouting, inactivation of pathogenic microbes, and increasing the safety of grains, vegetables, fruits, and other food goods (Heldman and Moraru, 2010; Kanatt et al., 2006).

This process uses ionizing radiation (IR) of specific strength to destroy the microbes of frozen food. Gamma rays, X-rays, and ultraviolet rays (UV) are natural IR; Electron beams, which are artificial sources of IR, are used for this purpose (Sommers and Fan, 2011). Vitamins, minerals, carbohydrates, and protein in food products are not affected at all by this process, but a minute amount of vitamins A, C, E, and B1 may be loosened.

Gamma rays are produced by Cobalt 60 (Co-60) (Ronholm et al., 2016), processed for some minutes to destroy microbes, and suitable for all foods. X-rays are produced by hitting electron beams on metal surfaces, processed for seconds, and are ideal for all food items to preserve them. The electron beam is produced by accelerated electrons for just seconds on thin products for preservation (Amit et al., 2017).

Smoking

Smoking is an ancient method in which wood containing formaldehyde and phenolic components (e.g., catechol, phenol, meta- and para-Cresol, and o-methylhydroquinone) are burned to preserve the food by dehydration. This method can maintain fish by adding flavor to food (Joardder and Masud, 2019).

Pulse electric field

It is a modern technique in which a pulse electric field with high voltage is applied to food (placed between two electrodes) for less than a second (Li et al., 2023) to preserve the food by killing vegetative cells. This process destroys all the gram-negative bacteria, but the spores are resistant, so it is useless against spores (Amit et al., 2017). It is a non-thermal technique and is also effective for liquid food samples.

High pressure preservation of food (HPP)

Ultra-high-pressure preservation is the only technique used to change the structure of food compounds (by changing the covalent bonds) and delay the onset of chemical and enzymatic changes that cause food deterioration. This method reduces the quantity and increases food temperature (Ashie et al., 1996). This process does not affect food’s vitamins, proteins, flavor, texture, and minerals (Koutchma et al., 2016). The environment-friendly process required minimal waste to discharge while keeping the nutritional value constant (Nielsen et al., 2009; Yeung and Huang, 2016). However, it is a highly cost-effective method requiring high process costs.

Packaging

Packaging is placing minimally processed or completely processed foods into paper, plastic, or metal containers. This technique is becoming foremost because it is used to transport food from factories to sailing points with minimal changes in the characteristics of food (Butnaru et al., 2019; Raheem, 2013; Vasile, 2018). It preserves vegetables, fruit juices, and dairy products (Alvarez et al., 2014). Packaging materials may interact with food inside, so coatings of bio-edible films are used to inhibit pathogenic effects and reduce the harmful interactions between materials and food. For instance, glycerol can be used to preserve potatoes by dipping them in it, and sorbitol or oil corn can be used for cheese protection (Romanazzi et al., 2016).

Nanoencapsulation is a technique that is mainly used for packaging solid or liquid food in nanocapsules (called shells) (Bratovcic and Suljagic, 2019). It helps the release of packed (canned) food flavor continuously during food storage. This method is not significantly used in developing countries but has various beneficial applications for food preservation in developed countries. Heating is done before packaging proteins – foods are heated and packed in cans or jars, but plant-extracted food items should not preheated to canning (Sahoo et al., 2015).

Biological methods
Fermentation

Fermentation is the most essential method for food preservation, using microorganisms like bacteria, fungi, and yeasts (Amara, 2024). These are used for fermentation of cereal food products, dairy, and meat products (Katz, 2001). It involves destroying carbohydrates using enzymes or microbes (Amit et al., 2017). This method is an alternative to many toxins-causing chemical techniques. Fermentation also enhances the digestibility, flavor, and nutritional value of food. There are many types of fermentation, including alcohol fermentation (yeast decompose the sugar and convert it into alcohol and carbon dioxide, which prevent the growth of aerobic microorganisms and increase the storage duration of food) (Sunte, 2023), vinegar fermentation (this method is used to preserve pickles), lactic acid fermentation (Heterofermentors produce lactic acid bacteria, ethanol, CO2 which has flavor in foods (Guizani and Mothershaw, 2007).

Bacteriocins

Bacteriocins are antimicrobial agents produced by bacteria and antagonistically affect other bacteria of the same species or may be different (Johnson et al., 2018). The first bacteriocin, Colicin, was discovered in Escherichia Coli in 1952 and has antagonistic activity by reacting with the inner membrane and inhibiting the synthesis of DNase and RNase, therefore inhibiting the growth of bacteria (Preciado et al., 2016). Commercially prepared lactic acid bacteria like Lactobacillus acidophilus and L. lactis are mainly used to preserve food. These bacteria are permeable to the membranes of other bacteria, extracting internal components. They may compete with other bacteria for nutrition (Staphylococcus aureus, Clostridium, and Enterococcus) and inhibit their activity by producing Enterocins A and B (broad inhibitors of Gram-positive bacteria (Ryan et al., 1996). Enterocin, Pediocin, Leucocin, Lactoccocin, and Carnocyclin are some common bacteriocins that are being used in food preservation.

Use of herbs and spices

Plants like guar gum, cloves, ginger, garlic, and mustard seeds produce many antimicrobial substances. When added to food items, these inhibit the growth of pathogenic bacteria and increase food’s shelf life, flavor, nutritional quality, and healthiness (Nilius and Appendino, 2013). These are compelling alternatives to chemical additives, including spices volatiles, which are very slow (Nilius and Appendino, 2013). Butylated hydroxyanisole (BHA) inhibits the growth of Gram-negative and Gram-positive bacteria and, when added to chicken, inhibits vegetative cells of Bacillus spp. (Shelef and Liang, 1982).

Chemical methods

Preservatives are the chemical or biological compounds that retard the growth of microorganisms and inhibit the deterioration caused by them hence, maintain the quality (texture, taste, odor, color) of food goods (Adams and Moses, 2008). Food preservatives may be artificial or natural. Bio preservatives (animal, plant, and microorganism sources) are grouped under natural preservatives, while (antioxidant and anti-enzymatic substances) are produced artificially for commercial purposes (Oladiji et al., 2024). Vinegar is a preservative that produces an acidic environment unfavorable for microbial growth. It is used to make pickled mangoes. Rosemary extract is used for oils, fats, margarine, and mayonnaise and is an antioxidant (Meyer et al., 2002). Different Chemical Substances are used for preservation, as shown in Table 1.

Table 1. Different chemical preservatives used to preserve food
Products Chemicals for preservation References
Fruits Sulfur dioxide, potassium sorbate Ahmadi et al. (2021)
Vegetables Vitamin C, sodium benzoate, calcium chloride Pravitha et al. (2024)
Meat Nitrites, nitrates, sodium chloride Pöhnl and Pöhnl (2024)
Fish Sodium nitrite, sodium chloride, potassium sorbate Mula and Alrubeii (2024)
Dairy products Sorbic acid, natamycin, sodium propionate Kovacevik et al. (2024)
Baked product Calcium propionate, sorbic acid, potassium sorbate Hussain and Bashari (2023)
Beverages Potassium sorbate, sodium benzoate, vitamin C Usaga et al. (2017)
Canned food products Citric acid, sodium chloride, EDTA Costa et al. (2014)
Download Excel Table
Salting and sugaring

Both salt and sugar work in the same way. When used in food like fish and meat, they cause dehydration (removing water from tissues) and help preserve and inhibit undesirable microbial growth (Dwivedi et al., 2017). Salt can be added on the top of meat or fish to cover correctly or mixed in water to create a brine in which microorganisms undergo plasmolysis (high osmotic pressure) and die, causing meat drying (Horner, 2011). Salt also removes the water from cabbage leaves and is also used to give protection and flavor to sauerkraut. The relationship between sugar, pectin, and acid is responsible for the intensity of food preserved. Jams and jellies are held by sugaring and remain soft, but if the sugar quantity is low, it will cause stiffness of jellies (Luh et al., 1986).

Other modern techniques of food preservation
Hydrolysis

The process in which the activity of the pectinase enzyme is retarded is called hydrolysis. If the pectin present in the peel of the fruit begins to destroy, it will produce pectinase enzyme for the destruction and spoilage and also results in the softening of the fruit. Pectin is produced by fruits to protect them from environmental negative effects and to extend their lives. Pectin methylesterase can prevent fruit spoilage (Ashie et al., 1996; Silva et al., 2018).

Ozone treatment

If vibrio species are present, the use of gases or dissolved forms of ozone can cause leakage of cell membranes of microbes, and ultimately, their death occurs (Ronholm et al., 2016). Seafoods like shellfish and other fish can be stored by this method. Water treated with ozone can increase the shelf life of fish by creating a pre-chilled environment (Ronholm et al., 2016).

Phage therapy

Two phage groups, siphoviridae PVP-I and VP phage obtained from V. Parahaemolyticus, were used to treat the community of V. Parahaemolyticus that is found in raw oysters (Yang et al., 2020).

Nanotechnology

Nanotechnology is an experimental technique using nano-size particles for processing, manufacturing, preservation, and packaging (Keshwani et al., 2015). Different nanomaterials produce biosensors that detect changes in food’s physiochemical and biological characteristics during packaging. Nanoparticles are used for heavy metal reduction, pesticides, drugs, and biofilm formation inhibition (Momin et al., 2013). Nanotechnology helps in food processing by anti-anticaking agents (improve consistency), gelating agents (improve food texture), and nano target carriers (protect flavor, aroma, and other ingredients in food) (Singh et al., 2017). It helps in food preservation by enhancing the physical properties of food, protecting against chemical deterioration, producing nano antimicrobial agents, and through nano-encapsulation (Momin et al., 2013). Mango meat, for example, is preserved and protected from being soft and brown by dipping in chemicals and forming a pectin coat (Tavassoli-Kafrani et al., 2022). Alginate and pectin form a gel-like coat that protects food from rotting and microorganisms. A common plasticizer is glycerol (Silva et al., 2018).

Market Economy Analysis of Food Preservation

Food preparation and preservation techniques are growing instantly because of consumers’ increasing demands for food texture, flavor, and aroma, so they predominate in the global economy. Both developed and developing countries are employing advanced technology for food processing. In the future, developing countries like China and India will hold a strong position (Debnath and Khan, 2017; Regmi and Gehlhar, 2005). In developed economies like the US, demand will decline to replace preserved food with fresh fruit, vegetables, or other products. The demand for chilled food products like fish, salad, meat, seafood, pasta, and pizza shows an upward trend. In the UK, more than 15% of the chilled food growth rate extended. It is expected to reach 70 billion by 2024 (Yeung and Huang, 2016). Pasteurization is continuously used to produce milk. It constitutes about 70% of the global liquid milk market (Kim, 2013). Moreover, according to some studies in 2025, nanoencapsulation will take significant credit for nanotechnology by encapsulating essential nutrients and delivering them to the targeted point within the body by nano delivery system (Ashraf et al., 2021).

Conclusion

Serious foodborne diseases occur from consuming spoiled food, so the most efficient and secure preserving techniques should be discovered, considering the economic feasibility and social responsibility. Increasing the stock storage interval without compromising the primary characteristics of food is still a significant challenge. Modern techniques like bio-packaging have proven to be effective in food processing by improving the shelf-life of food. However, many biopolymers are still under observation to produce edible films and coatings to safeguard food. In the future, nanotechnology will be an analytical and conventional method for nutrient delivery in the body. However, researchers also prioritize testing nanomaterials before placing them on the market. Biopreservatives are in more demand than chemicals. So, food production and preservation sectors are expanding rapidly to meet consumers’ needs. This review article has congregated different food types, mechanisms of food spoilage, and ways to preserve food. All these techniques are effective; they can maintain food without compromising quality. However, they also have some disadvantages that will be replaced with other food safety techniques.

Conflicts of Interest

The authors declare no potential conflict of interest.

Acknowledgments

Not applicable.

Ethics Approval

This article does not require IRB/IACUC approval because there are no human and animal participants.

Author Contributions

Conceptualization: Talib A, Joo ST.

Writing - original draft: Talib A, Samad A,

Writing - review & editing: Talib A, Samad A, Hossain MJ, Muazzam A, Anwar B, Atique R, Hwang YH, Joo ST.

References

1.

Adabi M, Naghibzadeh M, Adabi M, Zarrinfard MA, Esnaashari SS, Seifalian AM, Faridi-Majidi R, Tanimowo Aiyelabegan H, Ghanbari H. 2017. Biocompatibility and nanostructured materials: Applications in nanomedicine. Artif Cells Nanomed Biotechnol 45:833-842.

2.

Adams MR, Moses MO. 2008. Food microbiology. 3rd ed. The Royal Society of Chemistry, Cambridge, UK. pp 98-99.

3.

Agrahar-Murugkar D, Jha K. 2010. Effect of drying on nutritional and functional quality and electrophoretic pattern of soyflour from sprouted soybean (Glycine max). J Food Sci Technol 47:482-487.

4.

Ahmadi F, Lee WH, Kwak WS. 2021. A novel combination of sodium metabisulfite and a chemical mixture based on sodium benzoate, potassium sorbate, and sodium nitrite for aerobic preservation of fruit and vegetable discards and lactic acid fermentation in a total mixed ration for ruminants. Anim Biosci 34:1479-1490.

5.

Alnadari F, Al-Dalali S, Nasiru MM, Frimpong EB, Hu Y, Abdalmegeed D, Dai Z, Al-Ammari A, Chen G, Zeng X. 2023. A new natural drying method for food packaging and preservation using biopolymer-based dehydration film. Food Chem 404:134689.

6.

Alsaedi AWM, Al-Mousawi AJ, Al-Hilphy AR, Gavahian M. 2023. Non-thermal pasteurization of milk by an innovative energy-saving moderate electrical field equipped with elongated electrodes and process optimization. Innov Food Sci Emerg Technol 88:103445.

7.

Alvarez MV, Ortega-Ramirez LA, Melissa Gutierrez-Pacheco M, Thalia Bernal-Mercado A, Rodriguez-Garcia I, Gonzalez-Aguilar GA, Ponce A, Moreira MR, Roura SI, Fernando Ayala-Zavala J. 2014. Oregano essential oil-pectin edible films as anti-quorum sensing and food antimicrobial agents. Front Microbiol 5:699.

8.

Amara AA. 2024. Fermented food microbes and their preservative byproducts. In Antimicrobials in food science and technology. 1st ed. Gupta A, Prasad R (ed). CRC Press, Boca Raton, FL, USA. pp 30-71.

9.

Amit SK, Uddin MM, Rahman R, Rezwanul Islam SM, Khan MS. 2017. A review on mechanisms and commercial aspects of food preservation and processing. Agric Food Secur 6:51.

10.

Ashie INA, Smith JP, Simpson BK, Haard NF. 1996. Spoilage and shelf‐life extension of fresh fish and shellfish. Crit Rev Food Sci Nutr 36:87-121.

11.

Ashraf SA, Siddiqui AJ, Elkhalifa AEO, Khan MI, Patel M, Alreshidi M, Moin A, Singh R, Snoussi M, Adnan M. 2021. Innovations in nanoscience for the sustainable development of food and agriculture with implications on health and environment. Sci Total Environ 768:144990.

12.

Balasubramanian S, Viswanathan R. 2010. Influence of moisture content on physical properties of minor millets. J Food Sci Technol 47:279-284.

13.

Baranwal A, Srivastava A, Kumar P, Bajpai VK, Maurya PK, Chandra P. 2018. Prospects of nanostructure materials and their composites as antimicrobial agents. Front Microbiol 9:422.

14.

Blum D. 2012. Food that lasts forever. Available from: https://content.time.com/time/subscriber/article/0,33009,2108051,00.html. Accessed at Feb 15, 2024.

15.

Boye JI, Arcand Y. 2012. Current trends in green technologies in food production and processing. 1st ed. Springer, New York, NY, USA. pp 1-17.

16.

Bratovcic A, Suljagic J. 2019. Micro- and nano-encapsulation in food industry. Croat J Food Sci Technol 11:113-121.

17.

Butnaru E, Stoleru E, Brebu MA, Darie-Nita RN, Bargan A, Vasile C. 2019. Chitosan-based bionanocomposite films prepared by emulsion technique for food preservation. Materials 12:373.

18.

Chandra P. 2016. Nanobiosensors for personalized and onsite biomedical diagnosis. Available from:
. Accessed at Mar 2, 2024.

19.

Costa C, Conte A, Del Nobile MA. 2014. Effective preservation techniques to prolong the shelf life of ready-to-eat oysters. J Sci Food Agric 94:2661-2667.

20.

Dave D, Ghaly AE. 2011. Meat spoilage mechanisms and preservation techniques: A critical review. Am J Agric Biol Sci 6:486-510.

21.

Davis G, Song JH. 2006. Biodegradable packaging based on raw materials from crops and their impact on waste management. Ind Crops Prod 23:147-161.

22.

Davis KF, Downs S, Gephart JA. 2021. Towards food supply chain resilience to environmental shocks. Nat Food 2:54-65.

23.

Debnath M, Khan MS. 2017. Health concerns of pesticides. In Pesticide residue in foods: Sources, management, and control. Khan MS, Rahman MS (ed). Springer, Cham, Switzerland. pp 103-118.

24.

Dwivedi S, Prajapati P, Vyas N, Malviya S, Kharia A. 2017. A review on food preservation: Methods, harmful effects and better alternatives. Asian J Pharm Pharmacol 3:193-199.

25.

Fakolujo IY, Gbadeyan OM, Ibrahim FA, Oladele JO, Oladiji AT. 2024. Nutrition and fitness. In Nutrition and diet in health. Oladiji AT, Oladel JO, Ajay EIO (ed). CRC Press, Boca Raton, FL, USA. pp 169-180.

26.

Fennema OR, Powrie WD, Marth EH. 1973. Freezing injury and cryoprotectants. In: Low temperature preservation of foods and living matter. 1st ed. Fennema OR, Powrie WD, Marth E (ed). Marcel Dekker, New York, NY, USA. p 476.

27.

Fouladkhah AC, Thompson B, Camp JS. 2019. Safety of food and water supplies in the landscape of changing climate. Microorganisms 7:469.

28.

Fu PP. 2014. Introduction to the special issue: Nanomaterials—toxicology and medical applications. J Food Drug Anal 22:1-2.

29.

Gemechu T. 2015. Review on lactic acid bacteria function in milk fermentation and preservation. Afr J Food Sci 9:170-175.

30.

Gram L, Ravn L, Rasch M, Bruhn JB, Christensen AB, Givskov M. 2002. Food spoilage—interactions between food spoilage bacteria. Int J Food Microbiol 78:79-97.

31.

Guizani N, Mothershaw A. 2007. Fermentation as a method for food preservation. In Handbook of food preservation. 2nd ed. Rahman MS (ed). CRC Press, Boca Raton, FL, USA. pp 233-254.

32.

Gupta A, Kaur S. 2023. Biscuits. In Cereal-based food products. Shah MA, Sunooj, Shabir KV, Mir A (ed). Springer, Cham, Switzerland. pp 53-72.

33.

Harlan JR. 1976. The plants and animals that nourish man. Sci Am 235:88-97.

34.

He X, Hwang HM. 2016. Nanotechnology in food science: Functionality, applicability, and safety assessment. J Food Drug Anal 24:671-681.

35.

Heldman DR, Moraru CI. 2010. Encyclopedia of agricultural, food, and biological engineering. 2nd ed. CRC Press, Boca Raton, FL, USA. pp 869-872.

36.

Horner WFA. 2011. Preservation by curing (drying, salting and smoking). In Fish processing: Sustainability and new opportunities. Hall GM (ed). Blackwell, Chichester, UK. pp 51-76.

37.

Hoque M, Emon K, Malo PC, Hossain MS, Tannu SI, Roshed MM. 2023. Comprehensive guide to vitamin and mineral sources with their requirements. Indiana J Agric Life Sci 3:23-31.

38.

Hussain S, Bashari M. 2023. Shelf life enhancement of bread by utilizing natural and chemical preservatives. Emerg Chall Agric Food Sci 8:88-98.

39.

Igarashi Y, Eroshkin A, Gramatikova S, Gramatikoff K, Zhang Y, Smith JW, Osterman AL, Godzik A. 2007. CutDB: A proteolytic event database. Nucleic Acids Res 35:D546-D549.

40.

James SJ, James C. 2023. Chilling and freezing. In Food safety management. 2nd ed. Andersen V, Lelieveld H, Motarjemi Y (ed). Academic Press, San Diego, CA, USA. pp 453-474.

41.

Joardder MUH, Masud MH. 2019. Food preservation techniques in developing countries. In Food preservation in developing countries: Challenges and solutions. Joardder MUH, Masud MH (ed). Springer, Cham, Switzerland. pp 67-125.

42.

Johnson EM, Jung YG, Jin YY, Jayabalan R, Yang SH, Suh JW. 2018. Bacteriocins as food preservatives: Challenges and emerging horizons. Crit Rev Food Sci Nutr 58: 2743-2767.

43.

Jones GP, Lennard LB. 2020. Food composition and processing. In Food and nutrition. Wahlqvist ML (ed). Routledge, London, UK. pp 106-131.

44.

Kader AA, Zagory D, Kerbel EL, Wang CY. 1989. Modified atmosphere packaging of fruits and vegetables. Crit Rev Food Sci Nutr 28:1-30.

45.

Kanatt SR, Chander R, Sharma A. 2006. Effect of radiation processing of lamb meat on its lipids. Food Chem 97:80-86.

46.

Katz F. 2001. Active cultures add function to yogurt and other foods: Yogurt reinvents itself. Food Technol 55:46-49.

47.

Keshwani A, Malhotra B, Kharkwal H. 2015. Advancements of nanotechnology in food packaging. World J Pharm Pharm Sci 4:1054-1057.

48.

Kim TJ. 2013. Pasteurized egg maker eyeing global markets. Available from: https://www.koreatimes.co.kr/www/tech/2024/03/129_135030.html. Accessed at Mar 1, 2024.

49.

Kishimoto A. 1990. New food packaging materials: An introduction. In Food packaging. Kadoya T (ed). Academic Press, San Diego, CA, USA. pp 47-51.

50.

Koutchma T, Popović V, Ros-Polski V, Popielarz A. 2016. Effects of ultraviolet light and high-pressure processing on quality and health-related constituents of fresh juice products. Compr Rev Food Sci Food Saf 15:844-867.

51.

Kovacevik B, Veličkovska SK, Esatbeyoglu T, Cvetkovski A, Qamar M, Rocha JM. 2024. Biopreservation in flours and bread. In Novel approaches in biopreservation for food and clinical purposes. 1st ed. Garcia-Gutierrez E, Gomez-Torres N, Arbulu S (ed). CRC Press, Boca Raton, FL, USA. pp 130-204.

52.

Levine H, Slade L. 1988. Principles of “cryostabilization” technology from structure/property relationships of carbohydrate/water systems: A review. Cryo-Letters 9:21-63.

53.

Li Z, Yang Q, Du H, Wu W. 2023. Advances of pulsed electric field for foodborne pathogen sterilization. Food Rev Int 39:3603-3619.

54.

Lianou A, Panagou EZ, Nychas GJE. 2016. 1 - Microbiological spoilage of foods and beverages. In The stability and shelf life of food. 2nd ed. Subramaniam P (ed). Woodhead, Duxford, UK. pp 3-42.

55.

Luh BS, Kean CE, Woodroof JG. 1986. Canning of fruits. In Commercial fruit processing. Woodroof JG, Luh BS (ed). Springer, Dordrecht, Netherlands. pp 163-261.

56.

Martínez S, Carballo J. 2024. Physicochemical, sensory, and nutritional properties of foods affected by processing and storage series II. Foods 13:156.

57.

Mercier S, Villeneuve S, Mondor M, Uysal I. 2017. Time-temperature management along the food cold chain: A review of recent developments. Compr Rev Food Sci Food Saf 16:647-667.

58.

Meyer AS, Suhr KI, Nielsen P, Holm F. 2002. 6 - Natural food preservatives. In Minimal processing technologies in the food industries. Ohlsson T, Bengtsson N (ed). Woodhead, Cambridge, UK. pp 124-174.

59.

Momin JK, Jayakumar C, Prajapati JB. 2013. Potential of nanotechnology in functional foods. Emir J Food Agric 25:10-19.

60.

Monteiro CA, Levy RB, Claro RM, de Castro IRR, Cannon G. 2010. A new classification of foods based on the extent and purpose of their processing. Cad Saúde Pública 26:2039-2049.

61.

Mula NSA, Alrubeii AMS. 2024. The role of nisin, potassium sorbate and sodium lactate as additive in improving the chemical and qualitative characteristics of chilled ground beef. Iraqi J Agric Sci 55:195-205.

62.

Muzeza C, Ngole-Jeme V, Msagati TAM. 2023. The mechanisms of plastic food-packaging monomers’ migration into food matrix and the implications on human health. Foods 12:3364.

63.

Necidová L, Bursová Š, Ježek F, Haruštiaková D, Vorlová L, Golian J. 2019. Effect of preservatives on the shelf-life and sensory characteristics of pasteurized liquid whole egg stored at 4°C. Poult Sci 98:5940-5948.

64.

Nielsen HB, Sonne AM, Grunert KG, Banati D, Pollák-Tóth A, Lakner Z, Olsen NV, Žontar TP, Peterman M. 2009. Consumer perception of the use of high-pressure processing and pulsed electric field technologies in food production. Appetite 52:115-126.

65.

Nilius B, Appendino G. 2013. Spices: The savory and beneficial science of pungency. In Reviews of physiology, biochemistry and pharmacology. Nilius B, Amara SG, Lill R, Offermanns S, Gudermann T, Petersen OH, Jahn R (ed). Springer, Cham, Switzerland. pp 1-76.

66.

Nummer BA. 2002. Historical origins of food preservation. Available from: http://nchfp.uga.edu/publications/nchfp/factsheets/food_pres_hist.html. Accessed at Mar 2, 2024.

67.

Oladiji AT, Oladele JO, Ajayi EIO. 2024. Nutrition and diet in health: Principles and applications. CRC Press, Boca Raton, FL, USA.

68.

Pinstrup-Andersen P. 2009. Food security: Definition and measurement. Food Secur 1:5-7.

69.

Pöhnl H, Pöhnl T. 2024. Applications of different curing approaches and natural colorants in meat products. In Handbook on natural pigments in food and beverages: Industrial applications for improving food color. 2nd ed. Schweiggert R (ed). Woodhead, Cambridge, UK. pp 295-315.

70.

Poushi MK, Sharifi D. 2024. 2 - State-of-the-art in milk processing for improvement of the quality of pasteurized milk and UHT milk. In The microbiology, pathogenesis and zoonosis of milk borne diseases: Milk hygiene in veterinary and public health. Rana T (ed). Academic Press, San Diego, CA, USA. pp 19-27.

71.

Pravitha M, Dipika Agrahar M, Ajesh Kumar V. 2024. Recent developments in tomato drying techniques: A comprehensive review. J Food Process Eng 47:e14550.

72.

Preciado GM, Michel MM, Villarreal-Morales SL, Flores-Gallegos AC, Aguirre-Joya J, Morlett-Chávez J, Aguilar CN, Rodríguez-Herrera R. 2016. Bacteriocins and its use for multidrug-resistant bacteria control. In Antibiotic resistance: Mechanisms and new antimicrobial approaches. Kon K, Rai M (ed). Academic Press, Amsterdam, Netherlands. pp 329-349.

73.

Prokopov T, Tanchev S. 2007. Methods of food preservation. In Food safety: A practical and case study approach. McElhatton A, Marshall RJ (ed). Springer US, Boston, MA, USA. pp 3-25.

74.

Raheem D. 2013. Application of plastics and paper as food packaging materials-an overview. Emir J Food Agric 25:177-188.

75.

Rahman MS. 2020. Food preservation: an overview. Handbook of food preservation. 3rd (ed). CRC Press, Boca Raton. pp 7-18.

76.

Rahman MS, Labuza TP. 2007. Water activity and food preservation. In Handbook of food preservation. 2nd ed. Shafiur Rahman M (ed). CRC Press, Boca Raton, FL, USA. pp 465-494.

77.

Rahman MS, Velez-Ruiz JF. 1999. Food preservation by freezing. In Handbook of food preservation. 2nd ed. Rahman MS (ed). CRC Press, New York, NY, USA. pp. 635-666.

78.

Rahman R. 2014. Food preservation. Available from: http://en.banglapedia.org/index.php?title=Food_Preservation. Accessed at Mar 3, 2024.

79.

Rayaguru K, Routray W. 2010. Effect of drying conditions on drying kinetics and quality of aromatic Pandanus amaryllifolius leaves. J Food Sci Technol 47:668-673.

80.

Regmi A, Gehlhar M. 2005. New directions in global food markets. Economic Research Service/USDA, Washington, DC, USA.

81.

Romanazzi G, Smilanick JL, Feliziani E, Droby S. 2016. Integrated management of postharvest gray mold on fruit crops. Postharvest Biol Technol 113:69-76.

82.

Ronholm J, Lau F, Banerjee SK. 2016. Emerging seafood preservation techniques to extend freshness and minimize Vibrio contamination. Front Microbiol 7:350.

83.

Roos Y, Karel M. 1991. Plasticizing effect of water on thermal behavior and crystallization of amorphous food models. J Food Sci 56:38-43.

84.

Roudaut G, Debeaufort F. 2010. 6 - Moisture loss, gain and migration in foods and its impact on food quality. In Chemical deterioration and physical instability of food and beverages. Skibsted LH, Risbo J, Andersen ML (ed). Woodhead, Cambridge, UK. pp 143-185.

85.

Ryan MP, Rea MC, Hill C, Ross RP. 1996. An application in cheddar cheese manufacture for a strain of Lactococcus lactis producing a novel broad-spectrum bacteriocin, lacticin 3147. Appl Environ Microbiol 62:612-619.

86.

Sahoo NR, Panda MK, Bal LM, Pal US, Sahoo D. 2015. Comparative study of MAP and shrink wrap packaging techniques for shelf life extension of fresh guava. Sci Hortic 182:1-7.

87.

Salvato JA, Nemerow NL, Agardy FJ. 2003. Environmental engineering. 5th ed. John Wiley & Sons, New York, NY, USA. pp 680-694.

88.

Samad A. 2022. Antibiotics resistance in poultry and its solution. Dev J Community Serv 3:999-1020.

89.

Samad A, Alam AMMN, Kumari S, Jakir Hussain M, Lee EY, Hwang YH, Joo ST. 2024. Modern concepts of restructured meat production and market opportunities. Food Sci Anim Resour 44:284-298.

90.

Sandoval B. 2009. Perspectives on FDA’s regulation of nanotechnology: Emerging challenges and potential solutions. Compr Rev Food Sci Food Saf 8:375-393.

91.

Shelef LA, Liang P. 1982. Antibacterial effects of butylated hydroxyanisole (BHA) against Bacillus species. J Food Sci 47:796-799.

92.

Shenga E, Singh RP, Yadav AS. 2010. Effect of pasteurization of shell egg on its quality characteristics under ambient storage. J Food Sci Technol 47:420-425.

93.

Silva FA, Finkler L, Finkler CLL. 2018. Effect of edible coatings based on alginate/pectin on quality preservation of minimally processed ‘Espada’ mangoes. J Food Sci Technol 55:5055-5063.

94.

Singh DN, Bohra JS, Dubey TP, Shivahre PR, Singh RK, Singh T, Jaiswal DK. 2023. Common foods for boosting human immunity: A review. Food Sci Nutr 11:6761-6774.

95.

Singh T, Shukla S, Kumar P, Wahla V, Bajpai VK, Rather IA. 2017. Application of nanotechnology in food science: Perception and overview. Front Microbiol 8:1501.

96.

Slavov AM, Denev PN, Denkova ZR, Kostov GA, Denkova-Kostova RS, Chochkov RM, Deseva IN, Teneva DG. 2019. 3 - Emerging cold pasteurization technologies to improve shelf life and ensure food quality. In Food quality and shelf life. Galanakis CM (ed). Academic Press, Amsterdam, Netherland. pp 55-123.

97.

Sommers C, Fan X. 2011. Irradiation of ground beef and fresh produce. Nonthermal processing technologies for food. IFT Press, USA. pp 236-248.

98.

Steele R. 2004. Understanding and measuring the shelf-life of food. 1st ed. Woodhead, Boca Raton, FL, USA. pp 91-109.

99.

Sunte J. 2023. Effect of fungus, yeast, microorganisms on decomposition of human body and foods. Res Rev J Environ Sci 5:1-8.

100.

Tavassoli-Kafrani E, Gamage MV, Dumée LF, Kong L, Zhao S. 2022. Edible films and coatings for shelf life extension of mango: A review. Crit Rev Food Sci Nutr 62: 2432-2459.

101.

Tianli Y, Jiangbo Z, Yahong Y. 2014. Spoilage by Alicyclobacillus bacteria in juice and beverage products: Chemical, physical, and combined control methods. Compr Rev Food Sci Food Saf 13:771-797.

102.

Troller JA. 1986. Water relations of foodborne bacterial pathogens: An updated review. J Food Prot 49:656-670.

103.

Usaga J, Manns DC, Moraru CI, Worobo RW, Padilla-Zakour OI. 2017. Ascorbic acid and selected preservatives influence effectiveness of UV treatment of apple juice. LWT-Food Sci Technol 75:9-16.

104.

Vasile C. 2018. Polymeric nanocomposites and nanocoatings for food packaging: A review. Materials 11:1834.

105.

Vieira FN, Lourenço S, Fidalgo LG, Santos SA, Silvestre AJ, Jerónimo E, Saraiva JA. 2018. Long-term effect on bioactive components and antioxidant activity of thermal and high-pressure pasteurization of orange juice. Molecules 23:2706.

106.

Yang M, Liang Y, Huang S, Zhang J, Wang J, Chen H, Ye Y, Gao X, Wu Q, Tan Z. 2020. Isolation and characterization of the novel phages vB_VpS_BA3 and vB_VpS_CA8 for lysing Vibrio parahaemolyticus. Front Microbiol 11:259.

107.

Yeung CK, Huang SC. 2016. Effects of high-pressure processing technique on the quality and shelf life of Chinese style sausages. J Food Nutr Res 4:442-447.